Brindabella Motor Sport Club - Australian Rallying Forums Brindabella Motor Sport Club - Australian Rallying Forums

Go Back   Brindabella Motor Sport Club - Australian Rallying Forums > Open Forums > Australian Rallying Discussion
Menu
Home
About the BMSC
Forums
News
Downloads
Merchandise
Photo Gallery
Links
Join The BMSC
History
ACT Pointscores
ACT Register
Current ACT Regos
Arcade
Register
Rally FAQ
Members List
Rally Calendar
Mark Forums Read
 
ACT Series Sponsors
 
New To Rallying?
Our Rallying FAQ will get you headed in the right direction.
 
Latest Additions To Our Rally Results Archive
2011 South East Access Rallysprint
Added 28/04/11

1975 Travelplan 2BS 2MG Rally Supplementary Regulations
Added 28/04/11
 
Syndicate Our News
RSS Feed XML Feed
 
Follow us on Twitter
 
Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 09-04-2004, 10:16 AM   #31 (permalink)
Building a better mouse trap..
 
msgofast's Avatar
 
Join Date: 04-03-2003
Location: Kulnura/ NSW Central coast
Posts: 683
Rep Power: 16
msgofast is a grouse ozzie shearermsgofast is a grouse ozzie shearermsgofast is a grouse ozzie shearermsgofast is a grouse ozzie shearermsgofast is a grouse ozzie shearermsgofast is a grouse ozzie shearermsgofast is a grouse ozzie shearer
Ayes heard this last week, i was told the rod in the booster was ok now for grp N ?

it was something else.
__________________
cheers
Michael

www.msengineering.com.au

Engineering at it's finest......
msgofast is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-04-2004, 03:19 PM   #32 (permalink)
.._._..._ _
 
Ric Cary's Avatar
 
Join Date: 20-05-2002
Posts: 5,024
Rep Power: 138
Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.
Brakes FIA Grp N

" In the case of a car fitted with servo-assisted brakes, this device may be DISCONNECTED" that would mean uplugging the vacuum hose " the same applies for Anti-lock braking systems. if the anti-lock braking system (ABS) is disconnected or removed, the use of a mechanical rear braking distributor homologated by the manufacturer in a VO ( variant option) is authorised.

Unless there has been a bulletin released since last night you can`t run the rod all you are supposed to do is pull the vacuum off. it doesn`t even say you can replace the master cylinder sleeve it or do anybloody thing Which is the biggest load of crap I`ve seen in a long while you can`t drive the bloody things with antilag and vac assisted brakes cause sometimes you got vac and sometimes you don`t.
Ric Cary is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-04-2004, 04:20 PM   #33 (permalink)
Building a better mouse trap..
 
msgofast's Avatar
 
Join Date: 04-03-2003
Location: Kulnura/ NSW Central coast
Posts: 683
Rep Power: 16
msgofast is a grouse ozzie shearermsgofast is a grouse ozzie shearermsgofast is a grouse ozzie shearermsgofast is a grouse ozzie shearermsgofast is a grouse ozzie shearermsgofast is a grouse ozzie shearermsgofast is a grouse ozzie shearer
Reduce the throttle opening and anti lag, i know a few guys who do this, cheaper long term too...them trees cost money when ya hit em
__________________
cheers
Michael

www.msengineering.com.au

Engineering at it's finest......
msgofast is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-04-2004, 07:45 PM   #34 (permalink)
.._._..._ _
 
Ric Cary's Avatar
 
Join Date: 20-05-2002
Posts: 5,024
Rep Power: 138
Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.
Ok Karl I agree you can drive them,almost! try big cams and big lag it gets most exciteing to say the least sometimes you`ve got a nice pedal sometimes you`ve got a brick wall its a bit like the"this property is protected by Smith& Wesson two nights a week........you pick which night ". And I`m with you regarding GRP N thats why my new toy is going to be PRC well actually more like GRPn Plus. just the sensible mods its really not worth building a GrpN car unless you have your own massage the rules department on the payroll.
Ric Cary is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-04-2004, 01:43 PM   #35 (permalink)
Registered User
 
AussieNav's Avatar
 
Join Date: 09-07-2003
Location: Car or Plane, it's 50/50!
Posts: 512
Rep Power: 26
AussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or two
It is definately not impossible, or even near impossible to drive a Subaru without this illegal Gp-N modification.

Tony Sullens has a PRC WRX that runs a totally standard set-up with the master cylinder and I must say that his car also has a heap of grunt and also runs with Anti-lag.

Even though he runs a dog box in the car he doesn't frequently left foot break (which would cause vacuum problems) and seems to get around the stages at a fair pace to say the least.

You could make the mod for your PRC car then, but is not something that HAS to be done to a Gp-N car to make it safe or driveable though.

Talk to Southie or someone that knows a bit about anti-lag and the technical side of things and you won't have to start making your group-n car a cheater for know reason.
AussieNav is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-04-2004, 08:05 PM   #36 (permalink)
Building a better mouse trap..
 
msgofast's Avatar
 
Join Date: 04-03-2003
Location: Kulnura/ NSW Central coast
Posts: 683
Rep Power: 16
msgofast is a grouse ozzie shearermsgofast is a grouse ozzie shearermsgofast is a grouse ozzie shearermsgofast is a grouse ozzie shearermsgofast is a grouse ozzie shearermsgofast is a grouse ozzie shearermsgofast is a grouse ozzie shearer
Quote:
Originally posted by AussieNav

Tony Sullens has a PRC WRX that runs a totally standard set-up with the master cylinder and I must say that his car also has a >>>heap of grunt<<< and also runs with Anti-lag.
Must have a good tuner then

Quote:



Talk to Southie or someone that knows a bit about anti-lag and the technical side of things and you won't have to start making your group-n car a cheater for know reason.
arr....what would he know
__________________
cheers
Michael

www.msengineering.com.au

Engineering at it's finest......
msgofast is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13-04-2004, 11:29 AM   #37 (permalink)
Speechless.
 
Spac's Avatar
 
Join Date: 03-12-2001
Location: In the shed (Yass).
Posts: 11,312
Rep Power: 148
Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.
The scrutineers DO know about the rod-in-the-booster trick, and have chosen to turn a blind eye more than once before today... Like pretty well every single ARC round since the first Gp N turbo car with anti-lag turned up...

I have no doubt that it's a witch hunt, a travesty, a severe corruption of justice, and that someone should be strung up for it...

Interesting to know where the "motivation" for chasing the Atinsons came from - apparently not the Toyota team (apparetnyl they were dead-set against the DQ'ing), presumably not the Subaru team (manufacturer points), presumably none of the privateers (why would they care?)... Leaves Mitsu looking likely, but then again, they have benefited from some blind eyes being turned on similar matters before today...
__________________
Quote of the week, some guy on DBW:
"I'm a keyboard hero.

I've saved countless keyboards from drowning."
Spac is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13-04-2004, 02:11 PM   #38 (permalink)
Jme
Monkey
 
Jme's Avatar
 
Join Date: 09-08-2002
Posts: 2,500
Rep Power: 81
Jme is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Jme is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Jme is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Jme is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Jme is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Jme is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Jme is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Jme is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Jme is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Jme is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Jme is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.
Quote:
Originally posted by AussieNav

You could make the mod for your PRC car then, but is not something that HAS to be done to a Gp-N car to make it safe or driveable though.

Talk to Southie or someone that knows a bit about anti-lag and the technical side of things and you won't have to start making your group-n car a cheater for know reason.
Dale's right , It doesn't have to be done. We have never done it. Darren Gee's car is safe, so is Yama's and they stop. I'm sure many other cars around have the standard setup and are safe. You just run less throttle crack.... Craig's PRC car has a pedal box- at the request of our engine tuner for this exact reason.

The problem is that it is falsely viewed as a perceived safety issue by some. That's BS- It's a performance issue. It's illegal- they got caught.

The real issue is why were just the Atko's pinged when many cars in GpN had illegal brakes, (assumed- yes, but I bet I could target 3 areas on the brake system and get most of them) and is there "even-handed" scrutineering- or are some people targeted, and others not???
Jme is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13-04-2004, 02:33 PM   #39 (permalink)
Rev Monkey magazine reader
 
Bede's Avatar
 
Join Date: 03-12-2001
Location: "Respect is the ultimate currency"
Posts: 1,792
Rep Power: 74
Bede is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Bede is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Bede is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Bede is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Bede is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Bede is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Bede is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Bede is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Bede is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Bede is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Bede is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.
I thought ARCOM was worried about getting younger people into the sport. When a relatively young crew win and they get disqualified for something that is 'supposedly' a relatively common practice, I am sure that won't help the situation.

I can't speak for others, but it sure makes me want to try and make it into the ARC... NOT!
__________________
Proudly supported by:
Capital Steering and Suspension - Steering you in the right direction - 6280 5243


We use and recommend:
Engine Tuning by Mr White
Datsport - Datsun 1600 Specialists - 08 8186 2100
Dunlop Rally Tyres - Gary's Motorsport Tyres
Fifth Gear Motoring - Get the Driver's Edge
C&G Signs - Unit 1 / 60 Sheppard Street Hume ACT
Bede is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13-04-2004, 03:02 PM   #40 (permalink)
Speechless.
 
Spac's Avatar
 
Join Date: 03-12-2001
Location: In the shed (Yass).
Posts: 11,312
Rep Power: 148
Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.
Reasonably reliable source tells me that the booster was entirely gutted, not just 'rodded'... Saves oh, let me see... about 200gms I'd reckon...

Seems more than a little stupid that the 'rodding' is ignored wholesale, but saving one fifth of one kilogram is such a horrific breach of the rules...

Like JME said, if they enforce the rules fairly, evenly and sensibly, we'll be happy.
Like Bede said, if they want to appear to be a welcoming, positive sport, this is NOT the way to do it.
__________________
Quote of the week, some guy on DBW:
"I'm a keyboard hero.

I've saved countless keyboards from drowning."
Spac is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13-04-2004, 06:58 PM   #41 (permalink)
Registered User
 
AussieNav's Avatar
 
Join Date: 09-07-2003
Location: Car or Plane, it's 50/50!
Posts: 512
Rep Power: 26
AussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or two
I very much doubt that it was Mitsubishi who put the scrutineers onto this item.
Scott Pedders car was checked at scut for the same irregularities and was found to be all clear, which as Ed's car from last year would seem to suggest that that would clear all factory Mistu's and give them nothing to worry about.
But I do think if you listen to some of the stories and talk around the traps, it was not Misubishis doing at all!!
AussieNav is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13-04-2004, 07:12 PM   #42 (permalink)
Speechless.
 
Spac's Avatar
 
Join Date: 03-12-2001
Location: In the shed (Yass).
Posts: 11,312
Rep Power: 148
Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.
You're probably right - the rumours I've been hearing now say that it specifically was not the Mitsu team.
__________________
Quote of the week, some guy on DBW:
"I'm a keyboard hero.

I've saved countless keyboards from drowning."
Spac is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13-04-2004, 07:22 PM   #43 (permalink)
Registered User
 
AussieNav's Avatar
 
Join Date: 09-07-2003
Location: Car or Plane, it's 50/50!
Posts: 512
Rep Power: 26
AussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or twoAussieNav knows a thing or two
To clarify the FIA rule in discussion here, this is a note from ARC Scrutineer Barry Habgood as to how the rule is to be read and interpreted.


G'day all
Following recent events I thought I should clear up exactly what the FIA
means in Appendix J Article 254 6.5 "In the case of a car fitted with
servo assisted brakes, this device may be disconnected."
For the FIA this means you may change or modify the rod and go straight to the master cylinder piston, you may blank off the vacuum supply. No parts
may be removed from the booster or material added. (Apart from the above
rod, of course.)
There is nothing mentioned to allow changing the pivot point of the pedal.
Please contact me if you have any further questions.
AussieNav is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13-04-2004, 08:33 PM   #44 (permalink)
.._._..._ _
 
Ric Cary's Avatar
 
Join Date: 20-05-2002
Posts: 5,024
Rep Power: 138
Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Ric Cary is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.
For the FIA this means you may change or modify the rod and go straight to the master cylinder piston, you may blank off the vacuum supply.

Appendix J-Art254 Article 4

All modifications which are not allowed by the present regulations are EXPRESSLY FORBIDDEN.
the only work which may be carried out on the car is that neccesary for its normal servicing, or the replacement of parts worn through use or accident.
the limits of the modifications and fittings allowed are specified hereinafter.
APART FROM THESE,ANY PART WORN THROUGH USE OR ACCIDENT CAN ONLY BE REPLACED BY AN ORIGINAL PART IDENTICAL TO THE DAMAGED ONE




Appendix J-Art254 Article 6.5 Braking System
With the exception of the MODIFICATIONS AUTHORISED by this article the braking system must be original or homologated in option variant(VO)

"In the case of of a car fitted with servo-assisted brakes this device may be DISCONNECTED. the same applies for anti lock braking systems"

"It is permitted to add a spring in the bore of the calliper and to replace the seals and dust covers of the calliper"


Ok a couple of questions
1) Where is the bulletin allowing the Rod and yet not allowing the gutting of the booster cannister because the rules obviously say NOTHING is allowed except disconection
2) Without strengthening the cannister how does the rod work assuming their is a bulletin allowing it
3) Without removing or altering the inside of the Booster cannister how does the rod get to the master cylinder.once again assuming there is a bulletin allowing it
Ric Cary is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13-04-2004, 09:49 PM   #45 (permalink)
can't wait for the next rally
 
Lyndall's Avatar
 
Join Date: 29-01-2003
Location: Jerrabomberra
Posts: 876
Rep Power: 29
Lyndall knows a thing or twoLyndall knows a thing or twoLyndall knows a thing or twoLyndall knows a thing or twoLyndall knows a thing or twoLyndall knows a thing or twoLyndall knows a thing or twoLyndall knows a thing or twoLyndall knows a thing or twoLyndall knows a thing or twoLyndall knows a thing or two
Quote:
Originally posted by Spac
Interesting to know where the "motivation" for chasing the Atinsons came from...
I asked Col Trinder this at the BMSC meeting last week. The scrutineers have to advise at the first Stewards meeting of the event (for an ARC, usually held on the Friday after scrutineering but before the event proper starts) what items they intend to check on which placings (eg. brakes of 1st O/R vehicle, gearbox of 2nd O/R, engine of 1st F16, etc.). The letters advising what is to be checked are also pre-typed prior to the event starting.

As cars come over the podium/book in to the final control, whoever has finished in the identified placings in the identified categories is handed the relevant letter. So it was predetermined by the event scrutineers that 1st O/R was going to have their brakes checked. The event just unfolded that the Atkinsons were 1st for the weekend, so therefore their brakes had to be inspected.

Based on last year's form, most people would have expected the winner would come from one of the three factory teams or perhaps Scott Pedder - I don't think many would have predicted the Atkinson's would win a heat let alone the whole weekend (including Chris and Ben!).
Lyndall is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
ARC tipping comp Greg J Australian Rallying Discussion 0 14-07-2002 07:05 PM
WRC Tipping - Corsica Matt Sosi Australian Rallying Discussion 14 11-03-2002 06:33 PM
WRC Tipping?... fro Australian Rallying Discussion 5 27-01-2002 01:34 PM
Monte.... fro Australian Rallying Discussion 6 26-01-2002 07:50 PM


All times are GMT +11. The time now is 12:52 AM.



Powered by
vBulletin Version 3.8.4 - Copyright ©2000 - 2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd
vBadvanced CMPS v2.0.0 (vB 3.5)
Custom coding by Zenith and Matt
All content of this site is copyright unless noted otherwise and is not to be reproduced without the written consent of the webmaster
Page generated in 0.26310 seconds with 11 queries

Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.2.0