Brindabella Motor Sport Club - Australian Rallying Forums Brindabella Motor Sport Club - Australian Rallying Forums

Go Back   Brindabella Motor Sport Club - Australian Rallying Forums > Open Forums > Australian Rallying Discussion
Menu
Home
About the BMSC
Forums
News
Downloads
Merchandise
Photo Gallery
Links
Join The BMSC
History
ACT Pointscores
ACT Register
Current ACT Regos
Arcade
Register
Rally FAQ
Members List
Rally Calendar
Mark Forums Read
 
ACT Series Sponsors
 
New To Rallying?
Our Rallying FAQ will get you headed in the right direction.
 
Latest Additions To Our Rally Results Archive
2011 South East Access Rallysprint
Added 28/04/11

1975 Travelplan 2BS 2MG Rally Supplementary Regulations
Added 28/04/11
 
Syndicate Our News
RSS Feed XML Feed
 
Follow us on Twitter
 
Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 14-04-2005, 05:23 PM   #1 (permalink)
Speechless.
 
Spac's Avatar
 
Join Date: 03-12-2001
Location: In the shed (Yass).
Posts: 11,312
Rep Power: 148
Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.
Why the Excel Series is a good thing (and some other rambling).

Here's the simple version in blue:

I briefly drove the completed Excel that did 00 at Oberon, as many of you know.
Now, I won't pretend that a few kms down a tar road and back was a comprehansive test or anything, but:

Performance is OK - definitely faster than a Gemini-class Gemini.
The car feels really well tied down (and looked like it when they went past our speccie point).
They're dirt cheap, and parts are everywhere.
Power steering is good!

I honestly reckon that if you were comparing it to (say) a 180B, that you'd need one as good as Bede's to be confident of being faster than an Excel (assuming equal drivers, of course).

There's also some interest from Hyundai Aust to do some sort of deal on spare parts for competitors (a la Subaru). I don't know where that's up to, but it sounds promising. In any case, the retail prices on parts like front bumper skins are damn good (like literally one eighth the price of an RX-7 bit...).

I'm not saying that I intend to sell the RX-7 and replace it with an Excel, but if anyone is looking for a cheap car to start (or finish) their involvement in the sport, then an Excel should allow you to be reasonably competitive without spending a bomb, or having to scrounge the countryside for old car parts.
Not to mention the competiton among the Excels...

As they'd say on E-Bay; "Highly Recommended"


OK, here's where my customary dribble comes into it. Read on at your own peril.

Ever watched "Rally 83" or "Rally 84" video, covering the ARC and the NSW state series from those years? The cars are predictable - Dattos galore, with a few Lancers, Galants, Corollas and Mazdas (and the occasional bit of whackyness, like Carr's Fiat).
But the big thing is that the oldest cars out there are Datto 1600s.
Fast-foward nearly twenty five years to today, and what are the oldest cars we see? Bloody Datto 1600s...

A closer look at what's in current rally fields, and you can basically divide the cars into three groups:
1. Old, 1970s era* cars - Think 1600s, 180Bs, RX-2s and 3, and the rest.
2. New AWDs - think Evorex.
3. The others - late RX-7s, the occasional newer FWD, and, Um... Kev Gavin's VY Commodore and not a real lot else.

Now, most people can't afford/justify an EVOREX, so we'll ignore that option for this discussion.

If you go for option 1, you know it is a safe option. These cars are cheap to buy, and "everyone" knows how to make them work as rally cars. And they're still competitive, as is regularly proven by people with names like King, Fitzgerald, Murray, and Ewing.
Fine.

BUT, and it's becoming an increasingly big "but", these cars and their parts are getting hard to find, and therefore expensive.
Assuming you decide to build a Datto 1600, you'll have to look long and hard for a decent shell, and you'll probably pay a fairly significant amount of money for it. Then - if you want to be remotely competitive - you'll be looking for a pair of Webers, a decent diff ratio, a decent engine , an electronic dizzy, some extractors and a good exhaust, at a minimum.
Then you've gotta look at brakes and suspension - nobody is doing anything other than wasting their time with 240K brakes nowdays... So budget on a minimum of $2000 on a moderate brake upgrade and a set of Bilsteins.

At that point, you've spent a fair whack of money and a fair bit of time building yourself a typical, decent old Datto (think of something like Fro's 180B, or the Sophia's 1600).

And, I'm here to tell you that an Excel series Excel will beat it, without the need for anything other than the exhaust and shocks.

Yes, yes, I know we all hate Excels because of those idiots with 17" chrome rims and over-sized "compensatory" stereos, but those things are in the Excel series regs! And besides, is your rally car some sort of ego-massager, or is it something you pound over goat-tracks and throw at trees?

And, unlike the vast majority of old cars, it will take very little effort to find another body-shell if you bounce it off a tree... Further, because bodyshells are cheap and easy, you don't "need" a welded-in roll-cage to protect the last good 1600 shell known to mankind, so a $800 bolt-in jobbie from Bond can be transfered into any number of disposable bodyshells...

Basically, what I'm trying to get at, is that we've all been far too obsessed with 1970s cars for far too long, and these cars have basically reached their use-by date - their performance is fundamentally flawed, they're getting hard to get, they're becoming collectable (!) and all the rest.
I'm not having a go a anyone for having an old car - I react as badly as anyone when I hear nonsense like "old cars are bad for the sport".
What I am trying to say, is that a newer car will go just as fast as most of our old Dattos and Mazdas, with a LOT less hassle, and that we need to look outside the little square we currently live in.

To put it another way, if you're in the position where you need a new rally car, or you're advising someone on what sort of car they should buy, seriously consider whether "Get a 180B" is actually good advice anymore.

We've lost those competitors who used to buy a cheap road car one weekend, and within a month of casual weekend work, have a rally car ready to go. They've gone for a whole heap of different reasons, but one of the big ones, is that now they need to spend at least six months finding and building a car, and that it's beyond the technical and financial abilites of many people.
A little more awareness of how effective a lot of newer cars actually are, and we can (slowly) get them back into the sport, and enjoying themselves.

I can keep going, but I suspect that everyone has fallen alseep by now.
New cars work while nearly stock, old cars don't.
__________________
Quote of the week, some guy on DBW:
"I'm a keyboard hero.

I've saved countless keyboards from drowning."

Last edited by Spac; 14-04-2005 at 05:27 PM.
Spac is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 14-04-2005, 05:42 PM   #2 (permalink)
2007 VRC P3 Champion
 
Jimbo's Avatar
 
Join Date: 03-12-2001
Location: Melbourne
Posts: 1,295
Rep Power: 14
Jimbo is a dinkum ozzieJimbo is a dinkum ozzieJimbo is a dinkum ozzie
OMG.




Somebody please pinch me, or hit me, ot wake me up.

Did i just see Spac write that? Or am i seriously dreaming? Has he finally seen the light. Maybe he now understands why i have gone to such a car - Basicly the same but more grunt, and wider track!

Well done Spac!
__________________
2.09 in a stock Lantra around the Island - I'm happy with that!
Jimbo is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 14-04-2005, 05:43 PM   #3 (permalink)
Because I can...
 
Matt Dyne's Avatar
 
Join Date: 03-12-2001
Location: Hawker
Posts: 3,508
Rep Power: 31
Matt Dyne knows a thing or twoMatt Dyne knows a thing or twoMatt Dyne knows a thing or twoMatt Dyne knows a thing or twoMatt Dyne knows a thing or twoMatt Dyne knows a thing or twoMatt Dyne knows a thing or twoMatt Dyne knows a thing or twoMatt Dyne knows a thing or twoMatt Dyne knows a thing or twoMatt Dyne knows a thing or two
It's hurting me to write this, but that was a reasonably useful editorial.

Careful Spac...people might start to think you have something useful to say...that would really wreck your reputation!!
Matt Dyne is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 14-04-2005, 05:51 PM   #4 (permalink)
Need EFI? Get Megasquirt.
 
tortfeaser's Avatar
 
Join Date: 03-12-2001
Location: Deep south.
Posts: 5,854
Rep Power: 52
tortfeaser is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.tortfeaser is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.tortfeaser is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.tortfeaser is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.tortfeaser is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.tortfeaser is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.tortfeaser is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.tortfeaser is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.tortfeaser is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.tortfeaser is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.tortfeaser is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.
Post in Spokes.

Or better yet, get a Camira. Cheaper than an Excel, with more style, class, elegance, and dodgy plastics.
__________________
Marc Kelly
Now with MS'd JD Camira rally car. Don't laugh.
tortfeaser is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 14-04-2005, 05:53 PM   #5 (permalink)
2007 VRC P3 Champion
 
Jimbo's Avatar
 
Join Date: 03-12-2001
Location: Melbourne
Posts: 1,295
Rep Power: 14
Jimbo is a dinkum ozzieJimbo is a dinkum ozzieJimbo is a dinkum ozzie
And if you could let me have a bigger throttle body, that would be heaps great as well!
__________________
2.09 in a stock Lantra around the Island - I'm happy with that!
Jimbo is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 14-04-2005, 05:55 PM   #6 (permalink)
nuffin
 
Dave Ferris's Avatar
 
Join Date: 19-02-2002
Location: Canberra
Posts: 1,495
Rep Power: 14
Dave Ferris is a tops dinkum ozzieDave Ferris is a tops dinkum ozzieDave Ferris is a tops dinkum ozzieDave Ferris is a tops dinkum ozzie
Yeah good post spac and I have to agree with you, you do realise they are front wheel drive don't you and not made by Mazda?

I recon a group of us in them would make for some interesting rallying and possible fun times.
Dave Ferris is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 14-04-2005, 06:04 PM   #7 (permalink)
fro
Alpine Choker '09
 
fro's Avatar
 
Join Date: 03-12-2001
Location: Carwoola.
Posts: 7,742
Rep Power: 104
fro is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.fro is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.fro is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.fro is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.fro is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.fro is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.fro is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.fro is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.fro is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.fro is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.fro is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.
Quote:
Originally Posted by tortfeaser
Or better yet, get a Camira. Cheaper than an Excel, with more style, class, elegance, and dodgy plastics.
And about 10 years older, with no control class, and no direct manufacturer parts. Try buying a brand new bumper for a Camira, or getting a guard without having to fish through a wreckers.

That's part of Spac's point, that your missing. It's not that they're front wheel drive.

It's that they're plentiful, cheap, parts are easily accessible and affordable, and its still got 10 years of engine/suspension/other development over a Camira.
__________________
ARCom Mission Statement: "To become a premier motor sport category in Australia, providing an entertaining, popular and exciting medium in which aspiring competitors may participate, enjoy and achieve success at whatever level they desire, whilst ensuring the economic and social viability of the sport."

Last edited by fro; 14-04-2005 at 06:35 PM.
fro is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 14-04-2005, 06:14 PM   #8 (permalink)
TK
Good,Fast,Cheap...pick two!
 
Join Date: 26-04-2002
Location: Location: Location
Posts: 359
Rep Power: 11
TK got a bit of a rapTK got a bit of a rap
With costs spiralling, fields dwindling and even the "we have over 70 interested parties" Suby RS series with only 6 entries, you might find that the Excel series ends up being the one-make series of choice.

In fact, it could end up being the ARC series itself!

Quick...get your foot in the door now, get the experience early and you could become an Australian Champion!

Remember...you heard it here first....
__________________
Regs,

Tony Keeler
TK is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 14-04-2005, 06:16 PM   #9 (permalink)
BEN
Missing rallying already
 
BEN's Avatar
 
Join Date: 29-04-2004
Posts: 1,216
Rep Power: 27
BEN knows a thing or twoBEN knows a thing or twoBEN knows a thing or twoBEN knows a thing or twoBEN knows a thing or twoBEN knows a thing or twoBEN knows a thing or twoBEN knows a thing or twoBEN knows a thing or twoBEN knows a thing or twoBEN knows a thing or two
it will be good to see how they go this weekend
as they have put all 3 of them together.

ben.
Attached Files
File Type: pdf PCYC2005_seeded_list.pdf (8.6 KB, 176 views)
BEN is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 14-04-2005, 06:18 PM   #10 (permalink)
From Middle Earth
 
global's Avatar
 
Join Date: 04-07-2002
Location: Sydney
Posts: 761
Rep Power: 18
global is a grouse ozzie shearerglobal is a grouse ozzie shearerglobal is a grouse ozzie shearerglobal is a grouse ozzie shearerglobal is a grouse ozzie shearerglobal is a grouse ozzie shearerglobal is a grouse ozzie shearer
The excel at the Shakedown Rally Went pretty well.

Front wheel drive is not so dirty and wrong. You just need to be open minded about it. And adjust your driving to suit.

I have always had rwd and a turbo 4, but the age issue with one and the cost issue with the other prevented me from carrying on with them.

The Charade has been fun to drive, and its basically a grp N car.

I hope the Excel series grows. I wish them all well this weekend
global is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 14-04-2005, 06:30 PM   #11 (permalink)
Speechless.
 
Spac's Avatar
 
Join Date: 03-12-2001
Location: In the shed (Yass).
Posts: 11,312
Rep Power: 148
Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Spac is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.
Fro's pretty well nailed it - they're a good idea, and people should run them despite my moral objection to FWD... With PS, they're not even particularly torque steery.
__________________
Quote of the week, some guy on DBW:
"I'm a keyboard hero.

I've saved countless keyboards from drowning."
Spac is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 14-04-2005, 07:10 PM   #12 (permalink)
jem
has an rx2 story
 
jem's Avatar
 
Join Date: 21-01-2002
Location: on another planet
Posts: 1,012
Rep Power: 12
jem has some part of a clue
Karl... Where are the reputation points?
__________________
Versus... For all your computing needs - 6230 4899
jem is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 14-04-2005, 08:05 PM   #13 (permalink)
Chicken Man
 
Boris's Avatar
 
Join Date: 26-07-2004
Location: Plucking chooks
Posts: 243
Rep Power: 12
Boris is a tops dinkum ozzieBoris is a tops dinkum ozzieBoris is a tops dinkum ozzieBoris is a tops dinkum ozzieBoris is a tops dinkum ozzie
I do believe that Spac maybe onto something, for many years a peddled an old TA22 Celica and wished to be in something a little more up to date. I now find myself in the Trueno, and initially thought 'finally I made it' only to do the sums and realise that the Trueno is now, as old as the Celica was, when I started out. Have a look at most rally starting lists, except for the EVOREX's and the old pre 85's there is very little else in the field. I do realise that most of the 'eligable' post 85 cars are fwd, but, surely this is where the future of our sport is heading. I have even had a sponsor (just one) who told me plainly, get a newer car and I will support you more, he was reluctant to have his name splashed over a 30 year old car. We need to see some more modern cars out in the field, and ones that people at all levels of the sport can afford. Why is there no class for a non turboed 4wd? Surely these cars as they reach 10-15 years old would make decent rally cars, if they didn't have to compete with their turboed cousins. Just my thoughts, feel free to shoot me down.

Boris
__________________
Chickenman

Boris is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 14-04-2005, 09:32 PM   #14 (permalink)
Registered User
 
Join Date: 14-11-2002
Posts: 38
Rep Power: 10
bert is yet to show credentials
One make series are the best way to go rallying on a budget. They are fircely competetive and one of the best ways of finding out who is the quickest driver/nav combo. They are great 1st cars for anyone wanting to move up to more competitive things. Just look at some of the past Gemini winners: Rod Turnbull, Ian and Pete Menzies, Brett Wright(alright he finished 2nd!), Paul Pyvarra(won Aussie Cars in the ARC before running out of cash) and last years Gemini winner Paul Batten. If the Excels follow the Gemini theme of only allowing modifications that address the short comings of the std car, then they should be just as sucessful. Give it twelve months for a few more cars and few teething problems to be sorted and there will be some epic Excel battles.
Bean
bert is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 14-04-2005, 10:22 PM   #15 (permalink)
180B's are stylish beasts
 
Shabby's Avatar
 
Join Date: 05-03-2003
Location: Not in the crack house
Posts: 1,272
Rep Power: 73
Shabby is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Shabby is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Shabby is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Shabby is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Shabby is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Shabby is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Shabby is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Shabby is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Shabby is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Shabby is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.Shabby is a dead-set, dinky-di Ozzie Legend.
To give an example of cost to build and time required.
Car 1998 twin cam auto $850 (dings in every panel) 4 hours to remove trim and push out dings
Car went for roll cage on 30/3/04
Start work on car 3/4/04
Purchased -second hand Marsh seats , 1 Securon 3 inch harness,triangles/ first aid kit,Sump Guard (Automotive Gadgets), 4 new tyres, Struts, Bits and pieces, rally rego,steering wheel
Already had-harness,lights,tripmeter/intercom,helmet hammock.

Cost to get to first rally $6500
It will be Auto and have a standard exhaust but we will be there.

Shab.
Shabby is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On



All times are GMT +11. The time now is 08:34 AM.



Powered by
vBulletin Version 3.8.4 - Copyright ©2000 - 2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd
vBadvanced CMPS v2.0.0 (vB 3.5)
Custom coding by Zenith and Matt
All content of this site is copyright unless noted otherwise and is not to be reproduced without the written consent of the webmaster
Page generated in 0.31005 seconds with 11 queries

Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.2.0